Decentralized storage is no longer a novelty—it’s the backbone of many Web3 apps.
Yet not all protocols are cut from the same cloth. Shebly (a new “hot-storage” network backed by Aptos Labs & Jump Crypto) and IPFS (the battle-tested peer-to-peer protocol by Protocol Labs) share the same dream of a content-addressable web, but they approach it in very different ways.

TL;DR

Dimension	Shebly	IPFS
Primary goal	High-throughput, low-latency retrieval (“hot storage”)	Content-addressable file exchange
Data layout	Erasure-coded chunksets < 10 MiB	Immutable content-addressable blocks up to 256 KiB
Incentives	Mandatory paid reads + storage rewards settled on Aptos	None built-in (optional Filecoin or other layers)
Retrieval path	Dedicated fiber backbone → RPC gateway → Storage Provider	Peer discovery via DHT → Bitswap / GraphSync
Audit & slashing	Hybrid peer audits + on-chain proofs	Community pinning & best-effort availability
Latency	Milliseconds (cloud-like)	Seconds or more (depends on peers)
Replication cost	< 2× (k/n erasure coding)	User-defined—often full replicas
Best for	4K video, AI checkpoints, real-time analytics	Static websites, NFTs, verifiable backups
Maturity	Testnet / white-paper stage (2025)	Production since 2015, wide ecosystem

1. Architecture

Shebly

Hub-and-spoke design. Clients talk to regional RPC nodes that fan out data to contracted Storage Providers (SPs).
Erasure coding gives probabilistic durability with lower overhead.
Aptos smart contracts handle payments, commitments, and slashing.

IPFS

Pure P2P overlay. Every node can store and serve blocks; discovery happens via a DHT.
Content addressing means the hash of the data is its address—immutable by design.
Bring-your-own-incentives; raw IPFS has no native payment layer.

2. Performance & Latency

Shebly provisions a private fiber backbone between SPs and RPC nodes, then charges per-byte for reads—so SPs want to be fast. Millisecond latencies rival AWS S3.
IPFS depends on the luck of the peer graph. If many nodes pin your file near the requester, retrieval is quick; otherwise it can stall or fall back to public gateways.

3. Incentive Models

Layer	Shebly	IPFS
Storage	SPs stake tokens and earn capacity rewards; slashed for downtime	“Pinning” is voluntary unless paired with Filecoin or third-party pinning services
Retrieval	Readers pay tiny micropayments per chunk	Free; performance is “best effort”
Security	On-chain audits + slash	Social trust / optional Filecoin proofs

4. Data Availability & Durability

Shebly’s hybrid audits constantly test chunk availability off-chain, forwarding a random sample on-chain to prove honesty. If enough SPs disappear, erasure coding lets the network reconstruct the file.
IPFS treats availability as a social contract: you (or a pinning service) must keep the blocks online. Otherwise the CID still exists—just no node may serve it.

5. Governance & Ecosystem

Shebly is nascent and opinionated: Aptos-native, DeFi-friendly, but still forming its dev tooling.
IPFS boasts a decade-old ecosystem: gateways (Infura, Pinata), browsers (Brave), and protocols (libp2p, IPLD). It’s chain-agnostic and battle-tested.

6. Use-Case Fit

Use case	Shebly	IPFS
Streaming 4K video	✅	⚠️ (buffering)
AI model checkpoints (GBs)	✅	⚠️ (slow)
NFT metadata & images	⚠️ (overkill)	✅
Static website hosting	⚠️	✅
Big-data analytics spill	✅	🚫 (block size limit)
Immutable academic data	✅	✅

7. Which Should You Choose?

Need S3-like performance, willing to pay per read, and comfortable with Aptos? → Shebly (once mainnet).
Need censorship-resistant, chain-agnostic storage with a mature toolchain? → IPFS.
Hybrid stack is common: keep canonical data on IPFS/Filecoin, push hot slices to Shebly or a CDN.

Conclusion

Both protocols push the web toward a trust-minimized future, but they optimize for opposite ends of the storage spectrum.
IPFS prioritizes openness and interoperability, while Shebly bends over backward for speed and verifiable uptime—at the cost of tighter economic coupling and newer tech.

If your dApp lives or dies by read-latency (think live video or AI inference), keep an eye on Shebly’s upcoming mainnet.
For everything else, the IPFS toolbox remains a proven bet.

Stay decentralized, and choose the right tool for the job.

Browse other posts